Chapter 6: The Geography of Language

6.3 Distribution and Diffusion of language

Let’s begin this chapter with an exercise by looking at a map that shows global distribution of the major language families.

Exercise 

Examine this map of language distribution through ArcGIS. Click the hold to drag the map and use the +/- on the top left corner to zoom in and out and consider:

  1. How does the distribution of major language families align or not align with major world regions?
  2. Which regions have the most diversity in language families?
  3. What processes might explain how a language part of the Indo-European family ended up being dominant in a place far away from it’s origin point?
  4. White space appears and is not labeled. These areas are not completely unpopulated, so what kinds of languages do you think are present there?

From the map and section linked above, you’ll see the major language families associated with each major world region and how the distribution of language families spans world regions, even ones that are not connected by land.

All modern languages originate from an ancient language. The origin of every language may never be known because many ancient languages existed and changed before the written record. Root words within languages are the best evidence that we have to indicate that languages originated from pre-written history. The possible geographic origin of ancient languages is quite impressive. For example, several languages have similar root words for winter and snow, but not for the ocean. This indicates that the original language originated in an interior location away from the ocean. It was not until people speaking this language migrated toward the ocean that the word ocean was added to the lexicon (a catalog of a language’s words).

6.3.1 Diffusion of languages

So, how did these languages get WHERE they are? Check out the video below for a quick overview and then see below for more.

Languages move from their hearths to other places and find new speakers through various diffusion processes. Relocation diffusion occurs when migrants bring their native language to a new country, or when conquerors impose their language on the people they subjugate. Hierarchical diffusion happens when inhabitants of major cities invent and adopt new slang or expressions, which are then introduced to smaller towns. Contagious diffusion is exemplified by the spread of new slang within a school as friends mimic each other’s speech. As languages are introduced in new locations, they often borrow words and expressions from the native languages they encounter, creating a dynamic exchange. The most common theories regarding the diffusion of language families, particularly the largest one, Indo-European, are through these mechanisms.

1. Peaceful, passive interactions.

The Agricultural theory holds that the Indo-European language spread from its likely origin point, also known as a linguistic hearth,  of Anatolia in modern-day Turkey alongside farmers who moved further and further out from their agricultural hearth.  Agriculture provided the opportunity for settlements with large numbers of people residing in one spot needing a way to interact and communicate with one another.

2. Conquest/war/invasion.

In contrast with the agricultural theory, conquest theory or nomadic warrior theory refers to the claim that the Indo-European language family diffused due to violent expansion and take-over by people from Anatolia to other parts of Europe.

 

Fig. 2. Language families of the Old World and their suggested expansions. Map based on information in (87) and other sources. Numbered examples discussed in text are 1 (Bantu), 3a to 3c (Austro-Asiatic, Tai, and Sino-Tibetan, respectively), 6 (Trans New Guinea), 7 (Japanese), 8 (Austronesian), 9 (Dravidian), 10 (Afro-Asiatic), 11 (Indo-European). Other possible examples mentioned only briefly: A (Turkic), B (Nilo-Saharan)
Figure 6.3.1 Language families of the Old World and their suggested expansions. Click the image to see it on Wikimedia and enlarge it. Then, follow the tract of number 11 that starts in Mesopotamia and moves towards Europe and possibly from there towards India.
Source: “Language families of the Old World and their suggested expansions.jpg” by Jared Diamond and Peter Bellwood via Wikimedia Commons is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0.

3. Colonialism.

Philip II's realms in 1598
Figure 6.3.2 in 1494 the Spanish and Portuguese Empires divided the areas of the new territories as can be seen in the map. Click on the map for a closer view.
Source: “Philip II’s realms in 1598.png” by Trasamundo via Wikimedia Commons is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

A more contemporary but still historical example is that of  colonialism, which tends to involve violent forms of conquest usually coupled with less violent forms of influence, as a related mechanisms that facilitates language diffusion.

Colonisation map in 1800
Figure 6.3.3 Map of Colonial Empires in 1800. For a closer look click on the map.
Source: “Colonisation 1800.png” by Jluisrs via Wikimedia Commons is in the public domain.

Latin America provides a tidy example of this. The red vertical line on the map below, from the Library of Congress, divided territory in the “new world” between Spain and Portugal in 1794 as part of the Treaty of Tordesillas. Area to the west of the line came under Spanish colonial rule and area to the east, Portuguese.

The linguistic impact of this is evident today: Central and South America are largely Spanish-speaking (with notable pockets and second languages of various Amerindian and Indigenous languages) except for Brazil, where Portuguese is predominant. In fact, the reason this region is widely referred to as Latin America and people from this region are called Latinos/Latinas/Latinix(the latter term is a gender-neutral way to refer to Latino men and Latina women) instead of Hispanic America, for instance, is because of the two Indo-European linguistic influences of Spanish and Portuguese. Take a look at a colonial/second-language map of of Africa, and you’ll see a similar colonial legacy. Proselytizing, or trying to convert people to a particular religion, tends to be part of colonial practices and as such also plays a direct role in language diffusion.

4. Cultural imperialism and the internet? 

When thinking about how language–entire communication systems or even parts of the system, like particular words or even gestures–spreads today in the 21st century, we must consider forces of cultural imperialism, referring to how more indirect but strong cultural influences (largely US-American) are imposed on much of the world.  Take a look at the chart below and compare the most common internet languages with the most spoken languages.

Rank Language Internet Users Percentage
1 English 1,186,451,052 25.9%
2 Chinese 888,453,068 19.4%
3 Spanish 363,684,593 7.9%
4 Arabic 237,418,349 5.2%
5 Indonesian 198,029,815 4.3%
6 Portuguese 171,750,818 3.7%
7 French 144,695,288 3.3%
8 Japanese 118,626,672 2.6%
9 Russian 116,353,942 2.5%
10 German 92,525,427 2.0%
1-10 Top 10 languages 3,525,027,347 76.9%
- Others 1,060,551,371 23.1%
Total 4,585,578,718 100%

Figure 6.3.4 InternetWorldStats estimates of the number of Internet users by language as of March 31, 2020 retrieved from Wikipedia.

6.3.2 Distribution of Language Families

Some of the world’s major language families are:

  • Indo-European
  • Sino-Tibetan
  • Afro-Asiatic
  • Niger-Congo
  • Austronesian
  • Uralic
  • Austro-Asiatic
Human Language Families
Figure 6.3.5 Location of the Worlds Largest Language Families (Click the image to see it on Wikimedia.)
Source: “Human Language Families (wikicolors)-ar.png” by Original: Ish ishwar | Derivative: Bassem Fleifel via Wikimedia Common is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Languages within the same family that have a similar origin, vocabulary, and grammar relative to other members of the family; of these the Indo-European language family has the largest number of speakers today.  A language family can be  grouped into the same language subfamily such as Germanic or Romance languages.

Of interest to note is the fact that several lingua franca, languages that are used across a wide are by many people who are not necessarily native speakers of them, of the past (e.g. Latin, French) and present (e.g. English) also came from the Indo-European language family. Below, take a look at some of the subfamilies within the Indo-European language family.

  • Germanic subfamily (e.g. English, German, Swedish)
  • Romance subfamily (e.g. French, Spanish, Italian)
  • Slavic subfamily (e.g. Russian, Polish, Bulgarian)
  • Indic (or Indo-Aryan) subfamily (e.g. Hindi, Sinhalese, Bengali)
  • Iranian subfamily (e.g. Persian, Kurdish, Pashto)
Indo-European languages map
Figure 6.3.6. Map of the main Indo-European languages in Eurasia (Click the image to see it on Wikimedia.)
Source: “Indo-European languages map.png” by nerdy.maps via Wikimedia Commons is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0.

6.3.3 The World Languages – English, Spanish, Chinese

English: Derived from the Indo-European Language family tree, the Germanic family branch includes English, German, Dutch, and the Scandinavian languages. English is also widely spoken in regions that were once part of the British Empire, including most of North America.

English is spoken by more people than any other language worldwide, though many speak it as a second language; i.e. it is primarily spoken by non-native speakers. This prevalence is not because English is particularly easy to learn; it has borrowed extensively from other languages, leading to numerous irregular spellings and verbs, as well as a vast array of slang. English became the world’s most common language largely due to the economic, cultural, and military power of England.  The British Empire’s naval power and colonization efforts in the 18th and 19th centuries spread English globally.

However, English did not achieve its unique global dominance until after World War II, when the British Empire was in decline. Unlike the British, the spread of American English was not through colonization but through the United States’ rise as an economic, cultural, and technological superpower, which solidified English’s status as a truly global language.

A good example of how this works is evident in the global airline industry. The diffusion of technology and language often go hand in hand. Pilots of international flights talk to air traffic controllers on the ground in English, even if neither the pilot nor the ground control official is from an English-speaking country. Why? Partly it’s because the airplane was invented by Americans and partly because the British invented international commercial air travel. Thus, English speakers invented air travel, so others have tended to follow the rules and tendencies created by the pioneers. Consider other technologies invented by Americans but now used worldwide (internet, personal computers, iPhone, etc.). Many users of these technologies, especially the early adopters, find them easier to use if they know English. In addition,  of course, the massive cultural influence of Hollywood and American pop music and the jeans industry have also helped spread English worldwide.

Spanish: The world’s second most commonly spoken home language after Chinese  is Spanish, one of the many Romance languages that evolved from a common Roman ancestor known as Vulgar Latin. In this context, “vulgar” refers to the language used by common people, as opposed to Classical Latin. Other Romance languages include Portuguese, Italian, French, and Romanian, with up to two dozen additional ones such as Catalan, Romansh, and Sicilian.

Speakers of many lesser-known Romance languages often live in mountainous regions (like the Ladin people in the Italian Alps or the Romansh in Switzerland), on islands, or in other isolated areas, highlighting the role of geography in the formation and preservation of languages. While each language in this family shares hundreds of similar words and linguistic structures, they generally remain unintelligible to speakers of other languages within the same family.

Chinese: Nearly a billion people speak Mandarin Chinese, derived from the  Sino-Tibetan language family, making it the world’s most spoken language by native speakers.  Mandarin is one of several Chinese dialects, which can lead to communication difficulties within the country. For example, people from Beijing may struggle to understand those from Hong Kong who speak Cantonese, another dialect. Over the years, various systems have been used to translate Chinese into English, which is why older Americans (or older maps) might refer to China’s capital city as Peiping or Peking.Chinese uses a character-based writing system, known as logograms, which has a complex relationship with the spoken language. as they use a character-based orthography or writing system. These characters have also been adapted for use in other languages like Korean, Japanese, and Vietnamese, despite those languages not being in the Sino-Tibetan language family. Because Chinese characters represent whole words, literate Chinese readers must know over 3,000 characters. This is also true for other East Asian languages. The development of computer software and hardware for East Asian languages faced early challenges due to keyboards and cell phone screens being designed for alphabet-based systems used in the West, which were poorly suited for logogram-based languages.

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Introduction to Cultural Geography Copyright © 2024 by Barbara Crain is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book